Emmerdale fans believe they have identified Robert Sugden's next romantic interest, and the speculation spells trouble for Dawn Fletcher. Viewers are predicting that Robert (Ryan Hawley) might develop feelings for Joe Tate (Ned Porteous), who is currently dating Dawn.
The fan theories have emerged following Robert's dramatic return to the village earlier this year. He made a surprise appearance at his ex-husband Aaron's (Danny Miller) wedding to his brother John (Oliver Farnworth) in May.
Recent dramatic storylines
Since his return, Robert has been central to several high-profile plots that have kept viewers gripped. He stole Lewis Barton's (Bradley Riches) drugs and sold them to newcomer Ray Walters (Joe Absolom), before striking a deal with Kim Tate (Claire King).
Robert was also spiked during a date with Owen Michaels (Simon Haines), who was subsequently framed by John for Nate Robinson's (Jurell Carter) murder. Robert wasn't convinced by the accusations against Owen.
The tensions escalated when Robert announced plans to expose John, leading to a violent confrontation between the brothers. The clash culminated in Robert hitting his evil sibling over the head with a wrench.
The breaking point incident
Friday's episode saw Robert reach his breaking point during what should have been quality time with his nephew Harry (Adam Pryor). Victoria (Isabel Hodgins) had convinced Robert to spend time with the youngster.
After spotting Aaron chatting with Robert at the café, John decided to exact revenge by encouraging Harry to play loudly with his drum kit at home. The relentless drumming pushed Robert over the edge, causing him to lose his temper and yell at Harry just as John arrived.
John later explained to Aaron what had happened. "I was worried something like this would happen. You should have seen Harry, he was terrified, came running to me," he said.
Family tensions escalate
John continued his manipulation by telling Aaron: "I put [Robert] in his place, insisted he needs to get help. He's volatile. You know, he's put me in hospital, given Vic a black eye, and now he's terrifying little kids."
Aaron defended Robert, responding: "Yeah, but come on, he's not gonna hurt Harry, is he? He was always amazing with Seb." This response irritated John, who felt his husband was defending Robert again.
Fan speculation grows
The speculation about Robert and Joe Tate has gained momentum among devoted soap watchers on social media platforms. Joe returned to the Dales in December 2024 and has been causing chaos throughout the village while dating Dawn Fletcher (Olivia Bromley).
One Reddit user theorised: "I can't describe why but I have a theory that Joe and Robert will hit it off as another complication between Robert and Aaron, before John is gone for good." Another viewer commented: "I'm a die hard Robron fan but I'm not against Robert being with someone else for a while."
A third fan remarked: "I don't think it's going to happen but Joe already has more chemistry with Rob than he has with Dawn." A fourth enthusiast declared: "I would totally be on board with a Joe and Robert relationship."
Potential romantic complications
The speculation centres on whether this potential romance could threaten Joe's current relationship with Dawn Fletcher. If the fan predictions prove accurate, Dawn could find herself devastated by losing Joe to Robert.
Fan theories suggest the potential pairing could create another complication between Robert and Aaron. Emmerdale airs weeknights on ITV1 at 7.30pm and is available to stream from 7am on ITVX.
Sources used: "Daily Star", "Belfast Live" Note: This article has been edited with the help of Artificial Intelligence.
