Why America and Canada Must Unite as Allies Against China

by Gary Isbell February 27, 2025 tfp.org/why-america-and-canada-must-unite

Why America and Canada Must Unite as Allies Against China

At first glance, the United States and Canada seem like two siblings who grew up in the same neighborhood but chose slightly different paths. One drove a flashy car, dreamed big, and became the extrovert at every party. The other, while quieter and more contemplative, cultivated a reputation for politeness and pragmatic wisdom.

Despite their differences, these North American neighbors share more than just a border. Geography binds them, but shared values must unite them. Now, more than ever, these two countries must strengthen their alliance morally, economically, and militarily against a threatening China.

One of the most compelling arguments for deeper collaboration between the U.S. and Canada is their shared foundation in Christian traditions, morals and governing structures. Their legal systems’ moral underpinnings are rooted in common law, the rule of law, and individual freedom, contrary to China’s authoritarian communist regime.

Together, America and Canada can play a crucial role in preserving the best aspects of Western civilization.

America and Canada are natural allies in the truest sense of the word. They share the longest undefended border in the world, which is an extraordinary testament to mutual trust and respect. The cooperation between the two nations fosters seamless collaboration in energy production, trade and defense.

Together, North America is an unparalleled energy superpower. Canada’s vast reserves of oil, natural gas and critical minerals perfectly complement America’s vast resources and its ability to refine, export, and commercialize resources at scale. A cohesive U.S.-Canada supply chain would reduce dependence on inferior Chinese goods while innovating toward cutting-edge technologies and bolstering energy security for the West. Joining forces makes sense to counter China’s dominance in rare earth minerals and manufacturing.

Canada is not a competitor but an American partner. Trade between the two nations remains one of the most prolific globally—over $1.7 billion in goods and services are exchanged daily. By enhancing this economic interdependence and strengthening agreements designed for mutual benefit, America and Canada can solidify their status as a united economic front capable of countering China’s pursuit of dominance in global markets.

It is easy to assume that America and Canada are the same, except for their accents and a few preferences. However, while they share English and French heritage, cultural differences make each country uniquely exceptional. These differences are strengths, not obstacles.

The United States thrives on innovation, pushing boundaries, and raw ambition. In contrast, Canada offers balanced pragmatism, diplomacy, and a deep respect for international partnerships. If properly cultivated, the United States’ bold global leadership paired with Canada’s pragmatic wisdom is a win-win situation.

Those tempted to suggest that America simply absorb Canada as its 51st state must consider that independence and identity are paramount to fostering mutual respect. America and Canada are distinctly different nations with unique histories, cultures and origins. Amalgamation would suffocate qualities that make this relationship so vital. The focus should be on fostering and celebrating each country’s good elements while working in harmony toward shared goals.

The elephant in the room—or the dragon, as it were—is communist China.

Its disturbing appetite for expansion is a cause for great concern. From its aggressive military presence in the South China Sea to its self-serving Belt and Road Initiative, China is systematically extending its tentacles across the globe.

Canada, for example, has already faced China’s overreach in areas such as foreign interference in its affairs. Thus, maintaining distance is not merely an option—it’s a necessity.

A fortified U.S.-Canada alliance would send an unmistakable signal to Beijing. Economically, a united North America could reduce reliance on cheap Chinese imports, improve supply chains, and create a more balanced flow of trade. If Canada could upgrade its military, the combined strength of the two countries would ensure the safety of critical infrastructure and Arctic trade routes threatened by China and Russia.

America and Canada should not merge; they need to march forward together. By deepening their alliance, these two nations can amplify the power of their shared values, abundant resources and complementary strengths. They can defend the future of Western civilization against totalitarian enemies who are increasingly active in today’s world.